Journal of Resources and Ecology >
Selecting the Appropriate Urban Biodiversity Restoration Indices based on the Pressure-State-Response Model and a Multi-scale Management Problem Investigation in Zhuhai City
LI Fen, E-mail: lifen009@126.com |
Received date: 2021-08-10
Accepted date: 2021-12-22
Online published: 2022-04-18
Supported by
The International Cooperation Projects of Shenzhen Science and Technology Innovation Committee of China(GJHZ20190822173805220)
The International Science and Technology Cooperation Platform Construction Project from China Association for Science and Technology(2021ZZGJB071545)
Urban biodiversity is now recognized as playing a critical role in supporting global biodiversity. However, it is important to note that biodiversity is a systematic and holistic concept and prior studies have not generally focused on cross-border or multi-scale management problems. On one hand, the ecosystems of cities are interconnected with adjacent cities by natural landscapes, so they are like mosaics instead of being isolated. Urban biodiversity research demands the consideration of the continuity within an ecosystem. On the other hand, both active protection and passive restoration strategies for urban biodiversity should not only be developed by researchers or municipal government agencies, but more importantly, they should consider the real ecosystem management problems faced by multi-scale departments in order to build a practicable Pressure-State-Response (PSR) model. The solutions for these issues should be included in the analysis to form a complete and more effective urban biodiversity strategy. The study in this paper offers an answer to whether different scales of cities or districts should adopt the same biodiversity strategy; and therefore, the decision depends on whether the places are of the same importance to the global or regional ecosystem, or whether the ecological elements are connected to the adjacent cities/districts and the problems that multiple stakeholders care about.
LI Fen , GAO Nannan , PENG Rui , HE Longbin , LAI Yupei , YANG Shiqi . Selecting the Appropriate Urban Biodiversity Restoration Indices based on the Pressure-State-Response Model and a Multi-scale Management Problem Investigation in Zhuhai City[J]. Journal of Resources and Ecology, 2022 , 13(3) : 518 -527 . DOI: 10.5814/j.issn.1674-764x.2022.03.016
Table 1 Changes of species in various vertebrate groups in Zhuhai City |
Categories of vertebrate animals | Number of surveyed species | Decrease | Increase | |
---|---|---|---|---|
2010 | 2018-2019 | |||
Amphibian | 22 | 22 | 2 | 2 |
Reptiles | 54 | 49 | 6 | 1 |
Birds | 159 | 148 | 50 | 39 |
Mammals | 19 | 17 | 7 | 5 |
Total | 254 | 236 | 65 | 47 |
Note: Decrease represents species recorded in 2010 but not observed in the 2018-2019 survey; while increase represents species recorded in the 2018-2019 survey but not observed in 2010①(① Investigation Report on the Background of Terrestrial Wild Vertebrate Resources in Zhuhai City.). |
Table 2 Main locations and ecosystems of key protected birds species in Zhuhai City |
Location | Ecosystem | Species protection level | |
---|---|---|---|
National-II | Provincial | ||
Qi'ao Island | Wetland | 11 | 14 |
Hengqin Island | Wetland | 5 | 6 |
Huitong Village | Construction land | 2 | 4 |
Matou Village | Construction land | 3 | 9 |
Caolang Village | Construction land | 1 | 7 |
Hezhou north | Farmland | 2 | 5 |
Wuqing Village | Construction land | 3 | 5 |
Qingwu Village | Construction land | 2 | 3 |
Shalong Village | Construction land | 4 | 3 |
Table 3 Feedback on the main problems from municipal government departments |
Municipal department | Main problems indicated |
---|---|
Ecology and Environment Bureau | The calculation standards, regulations, and implementation rules of ecological compensation are unsound |
Bureau of Natural Resources | The existing forest land is of low quality, and the construction of high-quality water source forests is expected to be included in the ecological restoration; the criteria for determining the natural shoreline after restoration shall be clarified |
Housing Construction Bureau | There is a conflict between green space planning and urban regulatory planning; achieving a balance between green space occupation and compensation is difficult; improvements of the refinement of management and construction are required; the specific indicators of ecological restoration must be clarified |
Water Authority | Part of the dikes are occupied by enterprises; management authority is not clear |
Natural Resources Monitoring Center | The rescue force for wild animals is weak and urgently needs to be strengthened |
Mangrove Management Area | The relationship between the reserve and the surrounding communities and management issues should be studied |
Marine Environment Monitoring Center | There are approximately 20 to 30 species of red tide organisms in the coastal waters of Zhuhai |
White Dolphin Authority | Chinese white dolphins are listed as Zhuhai's ecological business card; the second phase of the rescue base facilities and maintenance funds are insufficient |
Table 4 Feedback on the main problems from district government departments |
District department | Main problem feedback |
---|---|
Gaolan Port District | The key to the transmission system at the municipal and district levels lies in funding; indicators should consider the differentiation of each district |
Doumen, Gaoxin, Jinwan and other districts | The scope of river management is not clear, and there are conflicts between urban planning and land planning |
Xiangzhou District | The balance between green space occupancy and compensation cannot be controlled at the district-management and implementation level; the maintenance cost of landscape ponds is high |
Wanshan District | Law enforcement is weak, and there are no relevant regulations to support the implementation of ecological restoration projects on uninhabited islands; the plan should not restrict economic development and should not be restricted too much during the biodiversity conservation |
Hengqin District | Approaches of how to link with Macau and utilize ecological resources need to be considered |
Toyama District | The restrictive conditions and mandatory tasks for the grassroots departments should be carefully considered; the district has undertaken the city's garbage disposal, and hopes that the ecological compensation will be executed |
Fig. 1 Conceptual diagram of the PSR model of biodiversity conservation in Zhuhai City |
Table 5 Planned wetland parks in Zhuhai City |
No. | Name | Area (ha) | Protection level |
---|---|---|---|
1 | Hengqin National Wetland Park | 327.4 | National level |
2 | Huafashui County Provincial Wetland Park | 67.0 | Provincial level |
3 | Qi'ao Mangrove Wetland Park | 460.0 | District level |
4 | Hengqin Coastal Wetland Park | 60.0 | District level |
5 | Nanhu Lake Wetland Park | 70.0 | District level |
6 | Dongwan Wetland Park | 12.0 | District level |
7 | Shili Lianjiang Wetland Park | 33.4 | District level |
8 | Damenkou Wetland Park | 95.0 | District level |
9 | Huangyanghe Wetland Park | 40.0 | County level |
10 | Jinwan Central River Wetland Park | 18.8 | County level |
Fig. 2 Land cover/land use changes in Zhuhai City from 1999-2018 |
Table 6 Land cover/land use statistics in Zhuhai City |
Land use type | 1999 (km2) | 2009 (km2) | 2018 (km2) |
---|---|---|---|
Arable land | 539.7993 | 427.2948 | 230.7276 |
Woodland | 513.4698 | 505.1610 | 655.2864 |
Construction land | 166.0491 | 336.8313 | 358.5105 |
Unused land | 35.8002 | 6.8040 | 74.5146 |
Ponds | 144.819 | 144.4491 | 156.8709 |
Waters | 129.5649 | 202.4496 | 138.9474 |
Tidal land | 206.2611 | 119.9592 | 128.0691 |
Fig. 3 NDVI (vegetation coverage) changes between 1999 and 2018. (a) Map of NDVI (vegetation coverage) change between 1999 and 2018; (b) Comparison of NDVI (vegetation coverage) change rates by area proportions in Zhuhai City. |
Table 7 Biodiversity pressure indicators |
Category | No. | Indices | Explanation | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Human activities | 1 | 1-1 | Agriculture, aquaculture, forestry management | Human activities |
1-2 | Livestock and poultry farms (households) in the restricted area | |||
1-3 | Increase in the use of pesticides and fertilizers (%) | |||
1-4 | Proportion of restricted areas in tidal flat (%) | |||
2 | Increased permanent residents per year | Population pressure | ||
3 | Annual number of tourists | Tourist pressure | ||
Urbanization and pollution | 4 | Land consumption per 10000 yuan of GDP (m2) | Construction occupation | |
5 | 5-1 | Percentage of sewage discharge up to the standard (%) | Impact of sewage discharge | |
5-2 | Domestic sewage treatment rate | |||
5-3 | Industrial wastewater discharge rate | |||
6 | Harmless treatment rate of domestic garbage (%) | Environmental pollution from garbage | ||
7 | 7-1 | Noise level (%) | Noise impact of urban construction | |
7-2 | Daytime noise level | |||
7-3 | Nighttime noise level | |||
Climate change and species invasion | 8 | Local woody plant index | The ability to adapt and respond to climate change | |
9 | The number of invasive alien species | Invasive alien species threat |
Table 8 Biodiversity status indicators |
Category | No. | Indices | Explanation | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Environment | 10 | Air Quality Index (AQI) | Air condition | |
11 | Water quality up to the standard rate of important rivers and lakes (%) | Aquatic animal and plant growth conditions | ||
12 | Proportion of coastal waters with good water quality | Growth conditions for marine aquatic animals and plants | ||
Ecological space | 13 | Permanent protected farmland area (km2) | Farmland Habitat | |
14 | Forest coverage rate | Forest and grass Habitat | ||
15 | 15-1 | Wetland rate (%) | Wetland Habitat | |
15-2 | Terrestrial wetland area | |||
15-3 | Coastal Mangrove wetland area | |||
16 | Green area rate of urban built-up area (%) | Urban ecological space Habitat | ||
Biodiversity | 17 | Comprehensive species index | Urban biodiversity | |
18 | Species richness | Biodiversity of the city |
Table 9 Biodiversity response indicators |
Category | No. | Indices | Explanation |
---|---|---|---|
Ecological conservation and restoration projects | 19 | Ecological restoration area of damaged mountains (km2) | Aimed at the problem of bare mountains |
20 | Ecological shoreline restoration rate (%) | Aimed at the problem of river or sea shoreline improvement | |
21 | The proportion of land used for ecological protection (%) | Responding to the systematic protection of “Convention on Biological Diversity” | |
Government hierarchical control, clear ownership | 22 | Ecological restoration plan | Ecological network |
23 | Proportion of total fiscal revenue for ecological compensation revenue (%) | Protect compensation and increase implementation | |
24 | Environmental protection investment as a percentage of GDP (%) | Capital investment | |
Grassroots and public participation | 25 | The proportion of government leaders participating in ecological restoration training (%) | Government participating |
26 | Participation of the public and enterprises in ecological restoration (%) | Public and enterprises participating |
Table 10 Data sources and statistics departments of the PSR model in Zhuhai City |
Index | Sources of statistics | Statistics department |
---|---|---|
Agriculture, aquaculture, forestry management | The 13th Five-Year Plan for the Development of Modern Agriculture in Zhuhai City | Agriculture and Rural Affairs Bureau |
Increased permanent residents per year | Statistical Yearbook | Bureau of Statistics |
Annual number of tourists | Statistics of Zhuhai City's Tourism Reception in 2020 | Culture, Radio, Television, Tourism and Sports Bureau |
Land consumption per 10000 yuan of GDP (m2) | Land consumption: The Land Change Survey in 2018; GDP: Zhuhai Municipal National Economic and Social Development Statistical Bulletin | Bureau of Natural Resources, Bureau of Statistics |
Percentage of sewage discharge up to the standard (%) | The 13th Five-Year Plan for Environmental Protection and Ecological Construction of Zhuhai City | Ecology and Environment Bureau |
Harmless treatment rate of domestic garbage (%) | Zhuhai Livable City Construction Index System Database | Bureau of Urban Management and Comprehensive Enforcement |
Noise level (%) | Environmental Quality of Zhuhai City in 2019 | Ecology and Environment Bureau |
Local woody plant index | Zhuhai Livable City Construction Index System Database | Bureau of Urban Management and Comprehensive Enforcement |
The number of invasive alien species | Investigation of Invasive Alien Plants in the Sea (Mikania micrantha, Spartina alterniflora, etc.) | Wildlife Conservation Institute |
Air Quality Index (AQI) | The 13th Five-Year Plan for Ecological Civilization of Zhuhai | Ecology and Environment Bureau |
Water quality up to the standard rate of important rivers and lakes (%) | Environmental Quality of Zhuhai City in 2019 | Water Authority |
Proportion of coastal waters with good water quality | Implementation Plan for Prevention and Control of Pollution in Coastal Waters of Guangdong Province | Ecology and Environment Bureau |
Permanent protected farmland area (km2) | The Third National Land Survey | Natural Resources Bureau |
Forest coverage rate | Zhuhai Forest Resources Archives Database; Zhuhai Forest Resources Second Class Investigation Report | Bureau of Urban Management and Comprehensive Enforcement |
Wetland rate (%) | The Third National Land Survey | Natural Resources Bureau |
Green area rate of urban built-up area (%) | 2018 Zhuhai National Economic and Social Development Statistical Communiqué | Zhuhai Municipal People's Government |
Comprehensive species index | Statistical Indicators of National Ecological Garden City | Bureau of Urban Management and Comprehensive Enforcement |
Species richness | National Ecological Civilization Construction Demonstration Cities and Counties Construction Indicators | City Wildlife Conservation Office |
Ecological restoration area of damaged mountains (km2) | Statistical Indicators of National Ecological Garden City | Bureau of Urban Management and Comprehensive Enforcement |
Ecological shoreline restoration rate (%) | Special Integrated Plan for Sponge City Drainage in Zhuhai City (2018-2030) | Natural Resources Bureau |
The proportion of land used for ecological protection (%) | National Ecological Civilization Construction Demonstration Cities and Counties Construction Indicators | Natural Resources Bureau |
Ecological restoration and ecological network construction planning | China Biodiversity Conservation Strategy and Action Plan | Natural Resources Bureau |
Proportion of total fiscal revenue for ecological compensation revenue (%) | Measures of Zhuhai City on Fiscal Balanced Transfer Payments; Measures of Zhuhai City on Fiscal Ecological Protection Transfer Payments | Finance Bureau |
Environmental protection investment as a percentage of GDP (%) | The 13th Five-Year Plan for Environmental Protection and Ecological Construction of Zhuhai City | Bureau of Ecology and Environment, Bureau of Statistics |
The proportion of government leaders participating in ecological restoration training (%) | Refer to the National Ecological Civilization Construction Model Cities and Counties Construction Indicators | Ecology and Environment Bureau |
Participation of the public and enterprises in ecological restoration (%) | Refer to the National Ecological Civilization Construction Model Cities and Counties Construction Indicators | Ecology and Environment Bureau |
[1] |
|
[2] |
|
[3] |
Central Committee of the Communist Party of China. 2019. Outline development plan for the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area. https://www.bayarea.gov.hk/en/outline/plan.html.
|
[4] |
|
[5] |
|
[6] |
Guangdong Provincial Bureau of Statistics. 2021. Communiqué of the Seventh National Census of Guangdong Province (No. 2). ttp://stats.gd.gov.cn/attachment/0/421/421309/3283428.pdf.
|
[7] |
|
[8] |
IPBES. 2019. Global assessment report on biodiversity and ecosystem services. https://www.eaere.org/policy/ecosystems-biodiversity/ipbes-2019-global-assessment-report-on-biodiversity-and-ecosystem-services/.
|
[9] |
|
[10] |
|
[11] |
|
[12] |
|
[13] |
Ministry of Ecology and Environment of the People's Republic of China. 1998. Sea water quality standard (GB 3097-1997). http://mee.gov.cn/ywgz/fgbz/bz/bzwb/shjbh/shjzlbz/199807/t19980701_66499.shtml. 1998-07-01. (in Chinese)
|
[14] |
|
[15] |
|
[16] |
|
[17] |
|
[18] |
|
[19] |
|
/
〈 |
|
〉 |