Ecotourism in China

A Review of Green Development in the Tourism Industry

  • School of Tourism Management, Beijing International Studies University, Beijing 100024, China

Received date: 2017-05-04

  Online published: 2017-09-27

Supported by

National Natural Science Foundation of China (41301161 and 41671527), Project of Top-notch Young Higher Level Teaching Team Building Support Plan in Beijing Municipal Universities in 2017(CIT&TCD201704067)


Green development has become an important concept and an effective way to sustainably develop the tourism industry. Studying tourism green development promotes the construction of regional ecological civilizations and sustainable development. We systematically reviewed research on green development in the tourism industry and divided this body of work it into two stages: a germination exploration stage under the concept of sustainable development; and initial development under the green development concept. In addition, some important green development research methods, conceptualization and connotation of green development, an index system of green development evaluation to measure efficiency and influencing factors, green development models, and regulations and standards of enterprise green development countermeasures are discussed. This review affirms China’s positive exploration and reference meaning to developing countries, and finds that the majority of research is qualitative; quantitative analyses are limited and a relevant theoretical system has not yet formed. Future research should deepen the content, enrich research methods and construct a theoretical system.

Cite this article

TANG Chengcai, ZHENG Qianqian, QIN Nana, SUN Yan, WANG Shushu, FENG Ling . A Review of Green Development in the Tourism Industry[J]. Journal of Resources and Ecology, 2017 , 8(5) : 449 -459 . DOI: 10.5814/j.issn.1674-764x.2017.05.002


[1] Ai F, Wang J. 2006. Welcoming the green tide of Olympic Games Beijing hotel industry will implement "green tourist hotel standard". Corporate Culture, (11): 43-45. (in Chinese).
[2] Ariadna G.M., Xavier G., Anna R. 2017. Mass tourism and water efficiency in the hotel industry: a case study. International Journal of Hospitality Management , 61: 82-93.
[3] Bai R., Qin S H. 2012. On the formation of green development thought in China. Theory Monthly, (7): 106-109. (in Chinese)
[4] Bo Su. 2013. Research on Green Hotels Based on Green Materials. Applied Mechanics and Materials , 2488(340): 325-328.
[5] Cai N, Cong Y J, Wu J W. 2014. Green Development and New Urbanization of China: A dual-dimensional analysis based on SBM-DDF Model. Journal of Beijing Normal University (Social Science) , (5): 130-139. (in Chinese)
[6] Cavaliere C. 2010. Sustainable agro ecotourism ventures for low-carbon societies. Paper presented at the meeting of the Recreation Values & Natural Areas Symposium, Otago, New Zealand.
[7] Chen Q, Li L. 2013. The construction of the Green enterprise culture of Hunan Tourist hotel under the era of low carbon. Journal of Wuhan Commercial Service College , (06): 27-29. (in Chinese)
[8] Chu Z S. 2015. Study on the evaluation and influencing factors of industrial green development level in China. Thesis of Hunan University. (in Chinese)
[9] Convention of Biological Diversity. 1993. Retrieved from. http: // convention/articles.asp (Last accessed 18 January 2013).
[10] Cui Z H, Li Y H. 2005. A study on measurement method and management of tourism destination's carrying capacity. Journal of Yanbian University : Natural Science, 31(2): 124-129. (in Chinese)
[11] DM Minoli, MMH Goode, MT Smith. 2015. Are eco labels profitably employed in sustainable tourism? A case study on Audubon Certified Golf Resorts. Tourism Management Perspectives , 16: 207-216.
[12] Eagles P. F. J., McCool, S. F., & Haynes, C. D. A. 2002. Sustainable tourism in protected areas: Guidelines for planning and management. Switzerland and Cambridge, UK : IUCN Gland .
[13] F D'Alessandro, S Menghini, E Pfoestl, et al . 2016. Green Building for a Green Tourism. A new model of eco-friendly agri-tourism. A griculture & Agricultural Science Procedia , 8: 201-210.
[14] Font X, Tribe J. 2001. Promoting green tourism: the future of environmental awards. International Journal of Tourism Research , 3(1): 9-21.
[15] Fukuyama, Hirofumi, William L. Weber. 2009. A Directional Slacks – based Measure of Technical Inefficiency. Socio-Economic Planning Sciences , 43(4): 274 -287.
[16] Guo X M, Huang S, 2017. Green efficiency of China's tourism industry——A modified three-stage DEA model analysis. Technoeconomics & Management Research , 4: 8-13. (in Chinese)
[17] Gai Y Q. 2013. Analysis and Establishment of Green Tourism Supply Chain Service Model. Logistics Technology , 32(6): 194-196. (in Chinese)
[18] Gao Z, 2016. Research on the actuality and evaluation of hotel green management. Market Modernization , (29). (in Chinese)
[19] Gössling S, Peeters P, Ceron J P, et al . 2005. The eco-efficiency of tourism. Ecological Economics , 54(4): 417-434.
[20] Guan H B, 2012. Exploration of low-carbon development mode in tourism scenic spots. Economic Tribune, (11): 116-118+129. (in Chinese)
[21] Guo Y J, 2015. Study on the evaluation and model of green development level of Ningxia Hui Colony restricted development ecological area. Ningxia University . (in Chinese)
[22] Han Y J, Wu P, Lin T. 2015. Regional tourism industry' efficiency measurement and comparative analysis based on carbon emissions. Geographical Research , 34(10): 1957-1970. (in Chinese)
[23] He D M. 2014. Research on green management of tourist hotels. Tourism Overview , (2): 123. (in Chinese)
[24] Hidinger, L. A. 1996. Measuring the impacts of ecotourism on animal populations: A case study of Tikal National Park, Guatemala. Yale Univ. Press , 49-59.
[25] Hoefle S W. 2016. Multi-functionality, juxtaposition and conflict in the Central Amazon: Will tourism contribute to rural livelihoods and save the rainforest? Journal of Rural Studies , 44: 24-36.
[26] Hu A G, Zhou S J. 2014. Green development: function definition, mechanism analysis and development strategy. China Population, Resources and Environment , 24(1): 14-20. (in Chinese)
[27] Hu J W, 1999. Green Marketing-The market Strategy Choice of deeping development of Shennongjia tourism. Journal Beijing Second Foreign Language Institute , (4): 50-54. (in Chinese)
[28] Huang D L, Xing H N, 2006. Research on natural Heritage protection law based on public property law theory. Research on the hot issues of resource-conserving, environment-friendly social construction and environmental resource Law Proceedings of the 2006 National Symposium on Environmental Resources Law. (in Chinese)
[29] Huang J H, Yang X G, Hu Y. 2014. Resource, environmental and economic coordinated and uncoordinated sources based on Cree Eie analysis framework. China Industrial Economics, (7): 17-30. (in Chinese)
[30] Huang L M. 2016. Discussion on the development of green shipping in Liangzihu scenic spot. Guangxi Normal University .(in Chinese)
[31] Huang M. 2006. Discussion on the Green Hotel. Truth Seeking , (S1): 148-149. (in Chinese)
[32] Irena Peršić-Živadinov. 2009. The environmental and economical impact of sustainable hotels. Ekonomska Istraz?ivanja , 2009, 22(2): 98-110.
[33] Jiang N P, Xiang R K. 2013. Some problems on the green development of China's economy. Contemporary Economic Research , (2): 50-54. (in Chinese)
[34] Kim, B, 1999. A study on green tourism in Japan. Journal of Korean Institute of Forest Recreation , 3: 1-13.
[35] KY Wu, SC Lu, YY Wu. 2014. A study on the evaluation factors of environmental education strategies for cultural heritage and low carbon tourism. Advanced Materials Research, 3607(1051): 632-640.
[36] Kuo N W, Chen P H. 2009. Quantifying energy use, carbon dioxide emission, and other environmental loads from island tourism based on a life cycle assessment approach. Journal of Cleaner Production, 17(15): 1324-1330.
[37] Kytzia S, Walz A, Wegmann M. 2011. How can tourism use land more efficiently? A model-based approach to land-use efficiency for tourist destinations. Tourism Management, 32(3): 629-640.
[38] Law A, Lacy T D, Lipman G, et al . 2016. Transitioning to a green economy: the case of tourism in Bali, Indonesia. Journal of Cleaner Production , 111: 295-305.
[39] Lei M D, 1997. Preliminary suggestions on the development of green tourism in Qinling Mountains in Xi' an. Journal of Northwest University (Philosophy and Social Edition) , 27(4): 85-90. (in Chinese)
[40] Leitis, E, 2011. The role of ecotourism in the reduction of anthropogenic load on Natura 2000 territories throughout Latvia. Scientific Journal of Riga Technical University, 7: 79-86.
[41] Li J Y, Deng X Z, Liu W D, et al . 2013. Conceptual framework of green development in western China. China Population Resources and Environment , 23(10): 1-7. (in Chinese)
[42] Li W Z. 2015. Measure and analysis on the regional differences of urban green development in Shaanxi province based on analytic hierarchy process. Research of Soil and Water Conservation , 22(5): 152-157. (in Chinese)
[43] Li X C. 2014. Analysis of green cost management and application in tourism hotels based on Hainan tourism hotel. Accounting for Township Enterprises in China , (10): 127-129. (in Chinese)
[44] Liu C R. 2008. Green idea of tourist industry development of Meizhou. Journal of Jiaying University , (5): 50-53. (in Chinese)
[45] Liu J, Liu H F, Yao X L. 2015. Study on green development efficiency of China’s coal industry. Industrial Technology & Economy, (10): 145- 150. (in Chinese)
[46] Liu J Y, Deng X Z, Liu W D, et al . 2013. The concept framework of green development in western China. China population, resources and environment, 23(10): 1-7. (in Chinese)
[47] Liu X H. 2012. A study on the green management mode of hotel enterprises from the perspective of circular economy taking the Grand hotel in Changsha as an example. Central South University of Forestry and Technology. (in Chinese)
[48] Liu Y, 2004. Green innovation of ecotourism products in western China. Beijing Economic Management Press . (in Chinese)
[49] Lu L W, Song D Y, Li X F. 2016. Green efficiency of urban development in the Yangtze River Economic Belt. China Population Resources and Environment, 26(6): 35-42. (in Chinese)
[50] Lu Q, Wu Q H, Zhou Y Z, et al . 2013. Industry green development evaluation index system and its application to the regional assessment of Guangdong province in China. Ecology and Environment Sciences , (3): 528-534. (in Chinese)
[51] Luo L W, Liang S R. 2016. Green technology innovation efficiency and factor decomposition of China's industrial enterprises. China Population Resources and Environment , 26(9): 149-157. (in Chinese)
[52] L Mccombes, F Vanclay, Y Evers. 2015. Putting social impact assessment to the test as a method for implementing responsible tourism practice. Environmental Impact Assessment Review , 55: 156-168.
[53] Ma X L, 2010. On the green marketing strategy of the hotels in tourist attractions——fake an example for Wuyishan national tourist attraction. Journal of Wuyi University , 29(1): 56-60. (in Chinese)
[54] Ma Y, Liu J. 2016. The core value and promotion strategy of tourism eco-efficiency under the green development background. Tourism Tribune , 31(9): 1-3. (in Chinese)
[55] Mayor K, Tol R S J. 2010. Scenarios of carbon dioxide emissions from aviation. Global Environmental Change , 20(1): 65-73.
[56] Mccool S., Butler R., Buckley R., et al . 2013. Is concept of sustainability Utopian: ideally perfect but impracticable. Tourism Recreation Research , 38 (2): 213-242.
[57] Michailidou A V., Vlachokostas C, Moussiopoulos N, et al . 2016. Life cycle thinking used for assessing the environmental impacts of tourism activity for a Greek tourism destination. Journal of Cleaner Production, 111: 499-510.
[58] Ming C Q, Zhong S H. 2017. Green growth evaluation indicator system for China tourist industry. Resource Development & Market, 33(2): 249- 252. (in Chinese)
[59] Moutinho V, Costa C, Bento J P C. 2015. The impact of energy efficiency and economic productivity on CO 2 emission intensity in Portuguese tourism industries. Tourism Management Perspectives, 16: 217-227.
[60] Nielsen S P, Sesartic A, Stucki M. 2010. The greenhouse gas intensity of the tourism sector: The case of Switzerland. Environmental Science & Policy , 13(2): 131-140.
[61] Ning B, He Y. 2007. Tourism development and water pollution: A case study of Lijiang ancient city. Chn Popu Res Envi, 17(5): 123-127. (in Chinese)
[62] Peeters P, Dubois G. 2010. Tourism travel under climate change mitigation constraints. Journal of Transport Geography, 18(3): 447-457.
[63] Peng H, Zhang J, Lu L, et al. 2017. Eco-efficiency and its determinants at a tourism destination: A case study of Huangshan national park, China. Tourism Management, 60: 201-211. (in Chinese)
[64] Qiao T, 2016. Analysis on the leading factors of green development of wetland tourism based on the chromatographic analysis. Science & Technology Vision , (12): 142. (in Chinese)
[65] Qin J X., Tang Y, Deng G P. 2012. Sustainable development of tourism industry in Jiuzhai-Huanglong Scenic Zone. Advanced Materials Research , 573-574: 755-761.
[66] Qu H, Xia J C. 2011. Actively promote the green transformation of tourism in China. Macroeconomics , (8): 35-39+64. (in Chinese)
[67] Ryan C. 2010. Ways of conceptualizing the tourist experience: A review of literature. Tourism Recreation Research , 35(1): 37-46.
[68] Schafer A, Victor D G. 1999. Global passenger travel: Implication for carbon dioxide emission. Energy, 24: 657-679.
[69] Sueyoshi, T., and M. Goto. 2011. DEA approach for unified efficiency measurement: assessment of Japanese fossil fuel power generation. Energy Economics, 33(2): 292- 303.
[70] Sun J K, Zhang J H, Liu Z H, et al . 2015. Estimation model of carbon dioxide emissions by regional tourism transportation and empirical analysis of Nanjing and Huangshan cities, China. Acta Ecologica Sinica , 35 (21): 7161-7171. (in Chinese)
[71] Sun J K, Zhang J H, Tang G R, et al . 2016. Review on carbon emissions by tourism transportation. Chn Popu Res Envi, 26(5): 73-82. (in Chinese)
[72] Tang C C, Zhong L S, Cheng S K. 2012. Research progress on carbon emissions in tourism industry. Progress in Geography, (4): 451-460. (in Chinese)
[73] Tian H J. 2009. Application of green macromolecule technology in the development of tourism recycle economy. Guangxi Journal of Light Industry, 25(8): 126-127. (in Chinese)
[74] Tu Z G. 2008. Coordination of environment, resources and industrial growth. Economic Research Journal , (2): 93-105. (in Chinese)
[75] Urioste-Stone S M D, Scaccia M D, Howe-Poteet D. 2015. Exploring visitor perceptions of the influence of climate change on tourism at Acadia National Park, Maine. Journal of Outdoor Recreation and Tourism , 11: 34-43.
[76] W Setyaningsih, TY Iswati, SriYuliani, et al . 2015. Low-Impact- Development as an implementation of the Eco-Green-Tourism concept to development Kampung towards sustainable city. Social behavioral Science , 179: 109-117.
[77] Wang B, Huang R J. 2014. China's regional green development efficiency and green total factor productivity: 2000-2010 empirical study based on the common boundary of parameters. Industrial Economic Review, (1): 16-35. (in Chinese)
[78] Wei L. 2013. Study on countermeasures for green logistics development in tourism scenic spots in China. Logistics Technology , (13): 116-118. (in Chinese)
[79] Wo X M, Huang S. 2017. Research on the green development efficiency of China's tourism industry under the constraint of carbon emission based on the modified three-stage DEA model. Technoeconomics & Management Research, (4): 8-13. (in Chinese)
[80] Wu B, Che X Z. 2013. Necessity and path choice of promoting green development in Shenzhen city. Special Zone Economy , (9): 26-28. (in Chinese)
[81] Wu G Q. 2015. On the dilemma and path of the green transformation of tourism. Journal of Henan Normal University (Philosophy and Social Sciences Edition , 42(5): 186-188. (in Chinese)
[82] Wu Y T. 2005. The concept of “green Hotel” and its application in China. Market Modernization , (23): 48-49. (in Chinese)
[83] Xiao J H, Wang M, Yu Q D, et al . 2016. Study on the ecological compensation standards of green development of island tourism——a case study of Putuo Golden Triangle in Zhoushan Islands. Resources and Environment in the Yangtze Basin , 25(8): 1247-1255. (in Chinese)
[84] Xu J Z. 2008. Experience on energy saving and consumption reduction in green tourist hotel. Hotel Modernization , (02): 64-65. (in Chinese)
[85] Xu P X, Si S L, Ya L W. 2016. Evaluation of the tourism traffic carbon footprint in Xingwen World Geopark. Applied Mechanics and Materials , 4278(851). (in Chinese)
[86] Xu T, Zhang Q J, Zhao L R. 2004. Review on the research of sustainable tourism development in China. Journal of Arid Land Resources and Environment, 18(6): 123-127. (in Chinese)
[87] Xu X. 2014. Research on green development level of resource-type cities in Heilongjiang province. Economig Rfsearch Cuide , (33): 163-166. (in Chinese)
[88] Yamazaki, M., Y. Oyama, J. Ohshima. 1997. Green tourism. Seoul : Ilshinsa.
[89] Yan W H. 2015. Green development connotation and green development index of rural tourism scenic spot. Forestry Economics, (8): 25-29+84. (in Chinese)
[90] Yang J H. 2015. An empirical study on the efficiency of green economy development in Hunan province. Central South University of Forestry and Technology. (in Chinese)
[91] Yin H G, Wang X T. 2006. The realizing form of green tourism. Ecological Economy , (3): 114-115. (in Chinese)
[92] Yu L, Yu Y Q, 1997. Green bring travel hot. Zhejiang Forestry , 3: 6. (in Chinese)
[93] Yu Q W, Cai H, Jiang B, et al . 2007. Problems and suggestions of implementing "green tourist Hotel" in Beijing. Research on Economics and Management , (09): 91-94. (in Chinese)
[94] Zhang J G. 2016. Research on the countermeasures of green logistics development in Beijing tourism scenic spot. China Business , 6: 21-22. (in Chinese)
[95] Zhang J H, Li M, Chen J, et al . 2012. Analysis of environmental Kuznets effect of tourism waste: Case study of Huangshan National Park. Acta Geographica Sinica, 67(11): 1537-1546. (in Chinese)
[96] Zhang R D, Cai C Z. 2009. On the interaction between green tourism and rural economic development. Economic Research Guide , 64(26): 64-66. (in Chinese)
[97] Zhang S H. 2007. Application of green supply chain management in ecotourism product development. Productivity Research , (2): 132-134. (in Chinese)
[98] Zhao J, 2011. Study on the evaluation of hotel green management taking Nanjing four hotels as an example. Nanjing University of Finance and economics . (in Chinese)
[99] Zhao L D, Zhang L, Xu L, et al . 2016. Mechanism of human capital, industrial structure adjustment and green development efficiency. Chn Popu Res Envi , 26(11): 106-114. (in Chinese)
[100] Zhong L S, Ma X Y, Zeng Y X. 2016. Progresses and prospects of ecotourism research in China. Progress in Geography , 35(6): 679-690. (in Chinese)
[101] Zhong L S, Zeng Y X. 2016. Green development concept brings new topics to China's tourism industry. Tourism Tribune, 31(10): 1-3. (in Chinese)
[102] Zhou X. 2013. Study on the construction of green supply chain model of rural tourism in urban economic radiation. Journal of Xinxiang University (Social Science Edition) , 27(6): 60-62. (in Chinese)
[103] Zhu L, Cao J. 2009. Establishment and application of Green degree evaluation system in hotel. Hotel Modernization , (6): 62-65. (in Chinese)
[104] Zhuang G Y. 2008. Low Carbon Economy Is Guiding the Direction of the World Economic Development. World Environment , (02): 34-36. (in Chinese)
[105] Zou T Q. 2005. On The Guidelines and Action Plans of Green Tourism in China. China Population, Resources and Environment, 15(4): 43-47. (in Chinese)