Orginal Article

Contrastive Study of the Circular Economy of Coal Resource City Based on Ecological Efficiency and C Model

  • 1. Institute of Green Development, University of Jinan, Jinan 250000, China;
    2. Institute of Geographic Sciences and Natural Resources Research, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, China

Received date: 2015-11-05

  Online published: 2016-09-20

Supported by

National Natural Science Foundation of China (41271556)


Being a developing country, the evaluation of Chinese circular economy should have its particular criterion that suits for specific national conditions. With the growth of economy, Chinese environmental loads should be permitted to increase at an appropriate speed. Based on this concept, this paper divides the process of evaluation into two parts which include evaluation of development level and evaluation of development performance. Firstly, this paper sets up a reference system which includes Zaozhuang City of Shandong Province, Jiaozuo City of Henan province, Shizuishan City of Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region and China that is regarded as a region respectively, analyzes the development level of circular economy of coal resource cities based on the evaluation indicator of ecological efficiency, and puts forward the future direction of circular economy of coal resource cities. Secondly, based on C Model of Circular Economy, this paper constructs the measurement model of development performance in which study regions are analyzed in a particular period that is from 2000 to 2020, and evaluates the development performance of circular economy for study regions according to the relationship of growth multiples between economic scale and environmental loads. We can draw several main conclusions: firstly, the development pathways of all four study regions belong to type Ⅱ which resource efficiency is preferred. Secondly, the comprehensive energy consumption efficiencies of coal resource cities were left far behind by China’s average level. Thirdly, the circular economies of all study regions have achieved remarkable progress. Fourthly, the development level of circular economy can be evaluated from two dimensions which consist of horizontal comparison method and vertical comparison method. Fifthly, C model is an appropriate development model that suits for Chinese national conditions and could be selected as an important method to evaluate regional development performance of circular economy.

Cite this article

YU Huilu, DONG Suocheng, LI Yu, LI Zehong, LI Fei . Contrastive Study of the Circular Economy of Coal Resource City Based on Ecological Efficiency and C Model[J]. Journal of Resources and Ecology, 2016 , 7(5) : 323 -333 . DOI: 10.5814/j.issn.1674-764x.2016.05.002


1 Ci F Y, Chen L. 2006. Mode of Circular Economy in Region. Scientia Geographic Sinica , (03): 273-276. (in Chinese)
2 Duan N. 2009. Theory of Circular Economy and Ecological industrial Technology [J]. Beijing: China Environmental Science Press. (in Chinese)
3 Duan N. 2010. Technology of Cleaning Production: Basic Technology of the Key to Solve Problems of Environmental Pollution. Beijing: Seventh China New Science and Technology Proceedings of the International Forum on Biodiversity Conservation and Utilization. (in Chinese)
4 Guo T Z, Li B Y, Duan N, et al . 2012. Cause Analysis of Scrap Recycling Industrial Cluster. Soft Science , (10): 1-4, 20. (in Chinese)
5 Han R L, Tong L J, Song Y N. 2011. Analysis of Circular Economy of Liaoning Province Based on Eco-efficiency. Acta Ecologica Sinica , (16): 4732-4740. (in Chinese)
6 Huang H P. 2015. Eco-efficiency on the Circular Economy Development Pattern in Jiangxi Province. Acta Ecologica Sinica, (09): 2894-2901. (in Chinese)
7 Zhang Y, Yang Z F. 2007. Eco-efficiency of urban material metabolism: a Case Study of Shenzhen. Acta Ecologica Sinica , (08): 3124-3131. (in Chinese)
8 Liu W. 2009. Summary of Theoretical Research on Cyclic Economy Development Model. Natural Resource Economics of China , (05): 24-26, 47. (in Chinese)
9 Lu Z W, Mao J S. 2003. Crossing “Environmental Mountain”——on the Increase and Decrease of Environment Impact in the Process of Economic Growth. Engineering Science, (12): 36-42. (in Chinese)
10 Sun F, Jia J F. 2011. Study on the circular economy model of Low-carbon specialty agriculture in Agriculture and animal husbandry compound area—A case study of Zhangjiakou City of Hebei Province. Rural Economy , (11): 114-117. (in Chinese)
11 Wang W, Lin J Y, Cui S Y, et al . 2010. Urban Sustainability Assessment Based on Eco-efficiency and its Application. Environmental Science , (04): 1108-1113. (in Chinese)
12 Wang Y R. 2006. Study on the Development Model of Circular Economy. Technology Economics , (2): 7-9. (in Chinese)
13 Yue B B, Li N, Wu Z, Sun Y. 2012. Construction of Circular Economy Mode for Integrated Eco- industrial Parks. Industrial Safety and Environmental Protection , (07): 88-90. (in Chinese)
14 Zhang Z J, Lu P, Zhou W. 2012. Research on circulating economic mode of mineral resources. China Mining Magazine , (S1): 177-180. (in Chinese)
15 Zhang Yan, Yang Zhifeng. 2007. Emergy analysis of urban material metabolism and evaluation of eco-efficiency in Beijing. Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae , 27(11): 1892- 1899. (in Chinese)
16 Zhu D J, Qian B H. 2006. A Research on China’s Circular Economic Development Mode and its Guarantee System. Copper Engineering, (01): 6-10. (in Chinese)