Comparative Evaluation between Water Parallel Pricing System and Water Pricing System in China: A Simulation of Eliminating Irrigation Subsidy

  • 1 Institute of Geographic Sciences and Natural Resources Research, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, China;
    2 University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing100101, China

Received date: 2016-01-05

  Online published: 2016-07-25

Supported by

National Natural Science Foundation of China (41271547, 41501604 and 41271546), the 57th China Postdoctoral Science Foundation


The reform in water pricing plays a critical role in agricultural production, which is believed to have great water savings potential. We consider eliminating irrigation subsidies as a simulation and conduct a comparative evaluation between the water parallel pricing system (WPPS) and the water pricing system (WPS), which are incorporated into two computable general equilibrium (CGE) models, respectively. The results prove that, compared with WPPS, WPS would contribute higher capacities for water savings with more farming imports and less loss in farming output; households in rural and urban areas would benefit from more income and food consumption, which would be matched by increasing farming imports. A policy recommendation is that eliminating the irrigation subsidy should pay more concerns on alleviating the negative effects on farming outputs. Moreover, improvements in agricultural labor mobility and water demand elasticity are needed to enable more focus on the water conservation policy, particularly in WPS.

Cite this article

SHEN Ming, ZHONG Shuai, SHEN Lei, LIU Litao, ZHANG Chao . Comparative Evaluation between Water Parallel Pricing System and Water Pricing System in China: A Simulation of Eliminating Irrigation Subsidy[J]. Journal of Resources and Ecology, 2016 , 7(4) : 237 -245 . DOI: 10.5814/j.issn.1674-764x.2016.04.001


[1] Aregay FA, Zhao MJ, Bhutta ZM. 2013. Irrigation water pricing policy for water demand and environmental management: a case study in the Weihe River basin. Water Policy , 15(5): 816-829.
[2] Dudu H, Chumi S. 2008. Economics of irrigation water management: A literature survey with focus on partial and general equilibrium models. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper Series, No. WPS4556. Washington, DC, USA
[3] Ge JP, Lei Y L, Tokunaga S. 2014. Non-grain fuel ethanol expansion and its effects on food security: A computable general equilibrium analysis for China. Energy , 65: 346-356.
[4] Huang QQ, Rozelle S, Howitt R, Wang J X, Huang J K. 2010. Irrigation water demand and implications for water pricing policy in rural China. Environment and Development Economics , 15: 293-319.
[5] Mamitimin Y, Feike T,Seifert I, Doluschitz R. 2015. Irrigation in the Tarim Basin, China: farmers' response to changes in water pricing practices. Environ Earth Sci, 73(2): 559-569.
[6] NBSC (National Bureau of Statistics of China). 2009. Input-Output Tables of China 2007. China Statistics Press, Beijing, China.
[7] Nitikin D,Shen CL, Wang J, Zou H F. 2012. Water Service Delivery Reform in China: Safeguarding the Interests of the Poor. Ann Econ Financ, 13(2): 463-487.
[8] Qin CB, Su Z, A Bressers H T, Jia Y W, Wang H. 2013. Assessing the economic impact of North China's water scarcity mitigation strategy: a multi-region, water-extended computable general equilibrium analysis. Water International, 38(6): 701-723.
[9] Shen DJ, Liu B. 2008. Integrated urban and rural water affairs management reform in China: Affecting factors. Phys Chem Earth , 33(5): 364-375.
[10] Shi MJ, Wang X J, Yang H, Wang T. 2014. Pricing or Quota? A Solution to Water Scarcity in Oasis Regions in China: A Case Study in the Heihe River Basin. Sustainability-Basel , 6(11): 7601-7620.
[11] Stone R. 1961. Input-Output and National Accounts. Organisation for European Economic Co-operation: Paris, France.
[12] van Heerden JH, Blignaut J, Horridge M. 2008. Integrated water and economic modelling of the impacts of water market instruments on the South African economy. Ecological Economics , 66(1): 105-116.
[13] Wang Z, Deng X Z,LiX, Zhou Q, Yan H. 2015. Impact analysis of government investment on water projects in the arid Gansu Province of China. Physics and Chemistry of the Earth, 79-82: 54-66.
[14] Warford J, Xie J. 2007. Water Supply Pricing in China: Economic Efficiency, Environment, and Social Affordability. China Addressing Water Scarcity from Analysis to Action Policy Note, Report No. 42176. World Bank, Washington, DC, USA.
[15] Wittwer G. 2012. Economic Modeling of Water: The Australian CGE Experience. Springer Dordrecht Heidelberg New York London.
[16] Xie J. 2009. Addressing China's water scarcity: recommendations for selected water resource management issues. World Bank-free PDF, No. 47111. Washington, DC, USA.
[17] Zhan J, Sun Z, Wang Z, Chen J, Li Z. 2015. Simulated water productivity in Gansu Province, China. Physics and Chemistry of the Earth, 79-82: 67-75.
[18] Zhang X, Li H. 2012. Water Cost Evaluation and Agricultural Production Policy Recommendations of Northwest of China. Research of Agricultural Modernization , 33(1): 82-85.
[19] Zhong L, Mol A P J. 2009. Water Price Reforms in China: Policy-Making and Implementation. Water Resources Management , 24: 377-396.
[20] Zhong S, Tokunaga S. 2014. A structure path analysis of the water supply in non-water sectors: the case of Shanghai. Studies in Regional Science , 44(4): 517-529.
[21] Zhong S, Okiyama M, Tokunaga S. 2015a. Impacts of Water Management System on Agricultural Production and Household Welfare within Urbanization of China: a Computable General Equilibrium Analysis. The Japanese Journal of Rural Economics , 17: 70-75.
[22] Zhong S, Shen L, Sha J H, Okiyama M, Tokunaga S, Liu L T, Yan J J. 2015b. Assessing the Water Parallel Pricing System against Drought in China: A Study Based on a CGE Model with Multi-Provincial Irrigation Water. Water , 7(7): 3431-3465.
[23] Zhong S, Sha JH, Shen L, Liu LT, Ke W L, Zhang C, Shen M. 2015c.Simulation of the Impacts of Different Pricing Systems of Water Resources on the Macro-Economy Based on CGE model on a Background of Urbaniation. Resources Science , 37(12): 2421-2429.
[24] Zhong, S., Sha, J.H., Shen, L., Okiyama, M., Tokunaga, S., Yan, J.J., Liu, L.T. 2016. Measuring drought based on a CGE Model with multi- regional irrigation water. Water Policy , on publishing. Available online: (accessed on 8 February 2016). DOI: 10.2166/wp. 2016. 120.
[25] Zhong S. 2014. Impact of Water Resources on Agricultural Economy and Rural Households in China: A Computable General Equilibrium Analysis. PhD diss., University of Tsukuba.
[26] Zhong S. 2016. A Study on the Impacts of the Pricing Systems of Water resources on Agricultural Economy Based on a CGE model. PhD diss., China University of Geosciences (Beijing).