Reflections on the Myth of Tourism Preserving “Traditional” Agricultural Landscapes

  • 1 KU Leuven, Geo-Instituut, Celestijnenlaan, 200E, 3000 Leuven, Belgium;
    2 School of Hotel and Tourism Management, Hong Kong Polytechnic University, 11 Yuk Choi Rd, Hung Hom, Hong Kong

Received date: 2013-06-12

  Revised date: 2013-08-07

  Online published: 2013-09-28

Supported by

Chinese Academy of Sciences Visiting Professorship for Senior International Scientists(Grant No.Y0S00100KD).


The renewed interest in "cultural landscapes" is a global phenomenon to be explained in a multi dimensional way.The process of revalorising traditional habitats,people and their way of living in a particular environment,is closely linked to the introduction of heritage as "a cultural,social and economic construct".The recognition of cultural landscapes as a new category on the world heritage list(UNESCO)since the 1990s,emphasises the importance of the human-environment interaction and the need for understanding the dynamics of landscapes in time and space.Values are changing and new opportunities emerge for a "dynamic preservation" of iconic landscapes and traditional communities.A cross disciplinary understanding of interacting processes is essential to plan and manage sustainable heritage(land)scapes.Various pilot projects and case studies-world-wide-lead to critical reflections about the sustainability of heritage landscapes and the sovereign role of tourism.The perspective of "Globally Important Agricultural Heritage Sites" (GIAHS),supported by economic resources generated by tourism,requires a research-based approach analysing opportunities and expectations,assessing strategic policies and top down politics.

Cite this article

Myriam JANSEN-VERBEKE, Bob McKERCHER . Reflections on the Myth of Tourism Preserving “Traditional” Agricultural Landscapes[J]. Journal of Resources and Ecology, 2013 , 4(3) : 242 -249 . DOI: 10.5814/j.issn.1674-764x.2013.03.007


Aplin G.2002.Heritage:Identification,conservation and management.Melbourne:Oxford University Press.

Aplin G and P Batten.2004.Open-minded geographers:Their potential role in integrated adaptive environmental management.Australian Geographer,35(3):354-62.

Aplin G.2007.World heritage cultural landscapes.International Journal of Heritage Studies,13(6):427-446.

Brouder P.2012.Tourism development against the odds:The tenacity of tourism in rural areas.Tourism Planning&Development,9(4):334-337.

Crouch D.2013.Space and place-making,space,culture and tourism (Chapter 31).In:Smith M and G Richards(Eds).The Routledge Handbook of Cultural Tourism.Abingdon,247-251.

Guibert M,Y Jean(Eds.).2011.Dynamiques des espaces ruraux dans le monde.Paris:Armand Collin,407.

Hall C M.2007.North-south perspectives on tourism,regional development and peripheral areas.In:M黮ler D K,B Jansson(Eds.).Tourism in Peripheries,From the Far North to the South.Wallingford CABI,19-37.

Hall M,A Lew.2009.Understanding and Managing Tourism Impacts.Routledge.

Harvey J B.1988.Maps,knowledge and power.In:Cosgrove D,S Daniels(Eds.).The Iconography of Landscape:Essays in the Symbolic Representation,Design and Use of Past Environments.Cambridge University Press.

Harvey D.2001.Heritage pasts and heritage presents:Temporality,meaning and the scope of heritage studies.International Journal of Heritage Studies,7(4):319-338.

Hawkins D,Chang B,K Warnes.2009.A comparison of the National Geographic Stewardship Scorecard Ratings by experts and stakeholders for selected World Heritage destinations.Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 17(1):71-90.

Jansen-Verbeke M.2007.Cultural resources and tourismification of territories.Acta Turistica Nova,1:21-42.

Jansen-Verbeke M,G Priestley,A P Russo(Eds).2008,Cultural resources for tourism:Patterns,processes,policies.New York:Nova Science Publishers.

Jansen-Verbeke M.2009.The territoriality paradigm in cultural tourism.Turyzm/Tourism,19(1/2):27-33.

Jansen-Verbeke M.2013,Mutation of cultural landscapes:The unplanned tourism map of Europe(Chapter 2).In:Costa C,E Panyik,D Buhalis (Eds).Trends in European Tourism Planning and Organisation.Abingdon:Channel View Publications.

Jansen-Verbeke M,B McKercher.2010.The tourism destiny of world heritage cultural sites.In:Pearce D,R Butler(Eds.).Tourism Research:a 20:20 vision.Oxford:Goodfellow Publishers,13.

Jansen-Verbeke M,Sun Y,Min Q.2013.Cultural heritage resources of traditional agricultural landscapes.In:Smith M,G Richards(Eds.).The Routledge Handbook of Cultural Tourism.Abingdon,273-282.

Jolliffe L.(Ed.).2013.Sugar heritage and tourism in transition.Bristol:Channel View Publications,235.

Koohafkan P and M J de la Cruz.2011.Conservation and adaptive management of Globally Important Agricultural Systems(GIAHS).Journal of Resources and Ecology,2(1):22-28.

Lowenthal D.1975.Past time,present place:Landscape and memory.Geographical Review,65(1):1-36.

McKercher B,H Du Cros.2002.Cultural tourism:The partnership between tourism and cultural heritage management.Binghamton:Haworth Press.

McKercher B,Ho P.2006.Assessing the tourism potential of smaller cultural attractions.Journal of Sustainable Tourism,14(5):473-488.

Min Q(Ed.).2009.Dynamic conservation and adaptive management of China's GIAHS theories and practices.Beijing:China Environmental Press,313.

Müller D K,B Jansson(Eds.).2007.Tourism in peripheries,from the far north to the south.Wallingford CABI.Roberts L(Ed.).2012.Mapping cultures place,practice,performance.New York:Palgrave MacMillan,309.

Salazar N.2012.Community-based cultural tourism:Issues,threats and opportunities.Journal of Sustainable Tourism,20(1):9-22.

Smith M,G Richards(Eds.).2013.The Routledge Handbook of Cultural Tourism.Abingdon:Routledge Handbooks.

Sun Y,M Jansen-Verbeke,Min Q,Cheng S.2011.Tourism potential of agricultural heritage systems.Tourism Geographies,13(1):112-128.

Tunbridge J,G Ashworth,B J Graham.2012.Decennial reflections on a"Geography of Heritage" (2000).International Journal of Heritage Studies,16:1-8.

Van Assche K,M Duineveld.2013.The good,the bad and the self- referential:heritage planning and the productivity of difference.International Journal of Heritage Studies,19(1):1-15.

Waterton E and L Smith.2010.The recognition and misrecognition of community heritage.International Journal of Heritage Studies,15(1-2): 4-15.

Wu Y,Xu H,W Eaglan.2011.Tourism-dependent development:The case of Lijiang,Yunnan Province,China.Journal of Policy Research in Tourism,Leisure and Events,3(1):63-86.

Yang L.2012.Impacts and challenges in agritourism development in Yunnan,China.Tourism Planning&Development,9(4):369-381.