Conceptual Framework for Economic Evaluation of Globally Important Agricultural Heritage Systems(GIAHS)：Case of Rice-Fish Co-Culture in China

doi:10.5814/j.issn.1674-764x.2013.03.003

Abstract

Abstract: The Globally Important Agricultural Heritage Systems(GIAHS)initiative was launched by the Food and Agriculture Organization(FAO)of the United Nations in 2002 with the aim of establishing the basis for the global recognition,dynamic conservation and adaptive management of outstanding traditional agricultural systems and their associated landscapes,biodiversity,knowledge systems and cultures.There is anecdotal evidence that designated GIAHS are economically better than non-GIAHS sites.However, there have not been done an economic analysis to prove this.Nor are any sophisticated economic performance criteria for GIAHS in place for a continuously monitoring of the functioning.Therefore,the main objective of this study is to conduct an economic valuation for a GIAHS system versus a similar non designated GIAHS system.For this,a Cost-Benefit Analysis(CBA)is chosen.The major constraint is the data availability.Therefore,a framework for economic analysis shall be developed with the intention to provide directions,assumptions,and data requirement to carry out an economic analysis and so give guidance on future inclusion of economic valuations of GIAHS.Theconceptual framework for economic assessment will use the Rice-Fish pilot site in China as a case study.The example calculations on the rice-fish co-culture(RFC)have to be taken cautiously due to data availability on different activities (tourism,marketed products on local and international markets)as well as comparison to similar systems.

Key words: phenology, Globally Important Agricultural Heritage Systems(GIAHS), Cost-Benefit Analysis (CBA), conceptual framework, economic assessment, Rice-Fish Co-Culture(RFC), China

Sonja BERWECK, Parviz KOOHAFKAN, Mary Jane Ramos dela CRUZ, MIN Qingwen, JIAO Wenjun, SUN Yehong, LIU Moucheng. Conceptual Framework for Economic Evaluation of Globally Important Agricultural Heritage Systems(GIAHS)：Case of Rice-Fish Co-Culture in China[J]. Journal of Resources and Ecology, 2013, 4(3): 202-211.

References

Bann C.1997.The economic valuation of tropical forest land use options -a manual for researchers.The Economy and Environment Program for SoutheastAsia(EEPSEA).

CNACH of IGSNRR.2011.Conservation and adaptive management of Globally Important Agricultural Heritage Systems(GIAHS):The China Experience.Progress Report December 2011.

Food and Agriculture Organization.(n.d.).Globally Important Agricultural Heritage Systems(GIAHS).Available from http://www.giahs.org/home/ en/(Accessed 10 September 2012).

Gittinger J P.1982.The economics of agricultural projects.Economic Development Institute,World Bank.

King D M,M J Mazzotta,K J Markowitz.2000.Ecosystem valuation.Dollar based ecosystem valuation methods.Available from http://www. ecosystemvaluation.org(Accessed 18 October 2012).

Lal P and M Keen.2002.Economic considerations in community based project planning and implementation(Vol.5).Technical Report 2002/5 South Pacific Regional Environment Programme(SPREP).

Liu M C,Zhang D and Li W H.2010.Evaluation of comprehensive benefit of rice-fishagriculture and rice monocropping:A case study of Qingtian County,Zhejiang Province.Chinese Journal of Eco-Agriculture,18(1): 164-169.(in Chinese)

Lu J and Li X.2006.Review of rice-fish-farming systems in China-One of the Globally Important Ingenious Agricultural Heritage Systems (GIAHS).Aquaculture,260:106-116.

Min Q W and Sun Y H.2007.Conservation and adaptive management of Globally ImportantAgricultural Heritage Systems(GIAH)-The GIAHS-Rice Fish Culture China Project Framework.China:CNACH of IGSNRR.

Min Q W,He L,Zhang D.2011.Agricultural heritage research in China:Progress and perspectives.Journal of Resources and Ecology,2(1):15- 21.

Pearce D,G Atkinson,S Mourato.2006.Cost-benefit analysis and the environment-Recent developments.Paris:OECD.

Sakuyama T and R Stringer.2006.Economic valuation of environmental services from agriculture:Stocktaking for incentive design.Roles of Agriculture Project.Policy Brief No.1,FAO.

Smith M,D de Groot,G Bergkamp.2006.Pay-establishing payments for watershed services.Gland,Switzerland:IUCN-The World Conservation

Union.

Sun Y H,M Jansen-Verbeke,Min Q W,Cheng S K.2011.Tourism potential of agricultural heritage systems.Tourism Geographics,13(1):112-128.

Sun Y H,Min Q W,Cheng S K.2009.Residents'attitudes towards tourism in a Globally Important Agricultural Heritage Systems pilot site:A case study in China.Chinese Journal of Population,Resources and Environment,7(1).

United States Environmental Protection Agency(EPA).2002.A framework of the economic assessment of ecological benefits.US:EPA.World Bank.2010.Cost-benefit analysis in World Bank projects.Washington D.C.:World Bank.

Xie J,Hu L,Tang J,et al.2011a.Ecological mechanisms underlying the sustainability of the agricultural heritage rice-fish co culture system.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,108(50).

Xie J,Wu X,Tang J,et al.2011b.Conservation of traditional rice varieties in a Globally Important Agricultural Heritage System(GIAHS):Rice-Fish Co-culture.Agricultural Sciences in China,10(5):754-761.

Zhang D,Min Q W,Liu M C,et al.2012.Economic tradeoff between traditional and modern agriculture:A case study in Congjiang County,Guizhou Province,China.Environmental Science&Engineering, 6(5):743-752.

[1]	HAN Zhiyong, LI Tao, LIU Ximei. Temporal and Spatial Characteristics and Evolution of China’s Inbound Tourism Carbon Footprint [J]. Journal of Resources and Ecology, 2021, 12(1): 56-67.
[2]	Sydney M. GREENFIELD, Aliana C. NORRIS, Joseph P. LAMBERT, Wu liji, Se yongjun, ZHAN Jinqi, MA Bing, LI Deng, SHI Kun, Philip RIORDAN. Ungulate Mortality due to Fencing and Perceptions of Pasture Fences in Part of the Future Qilianshan National Park [J]. Journal of Resources and Ecology, 2021, 12(1): 99-109.
[3]	ZHONG Yang, LIN Aiwen, ZHOU Zhigao, HE Lijie, YUAN Moxi. Economic Development Status of the Countries along the Belt and Road and Their Correlations with Population and Carbon Emissions [J]. Journal of Resources and Ecology, 2020, 11(6): 539-548.
[4]	WANG Xue, LI Xiubin. Impacts of Land Fragmentation and Cropping System on the Productivity and Efficiency of Grain Producers in the North China Plain: Taking Cangxian County of Hebei Province as an Example [J]. Journal of Resources and Ecology, 2020, 11(6): 580-588.
[5]	TAO Hui, GAO Jing, CHEN Kaiqiang. Space Changes in the Rural Tourism Area of Mufu Town, Hubei Province, China [J]. Journal of Resources and Ecology, 2020, 11(6): 633-644.
[6]	LIU Xianzhao*. A Comparative Decomposition Analysis of the Factors Driving Energy-related Carbon Emissions from Three Typical Provinces in China: Jiangsu, Henan and Inner Mongolia [J]. Journal of Resources and Ecology, 2020, 11(5): 483-498.
[7]	LU Chunxia, LIU Aimin, XIAO Yu, LIU Xiaojie, XIE Gaodi, CHENG Shengkui. Changes in China’s Grain Production Pattern and the Effects of Urbanization and Dietary Structure [J]. Journal of Resources and Ecology, 2020, 11(4): 358-365.
[8]	LIANG Yuting, HU Yunfeng, HAN Yueqi. Spatial Distribution and Dynamic Changes in Research Hotspots for Desertification in China based on Big Data from CNKI [J]. Journal of Resources and Ecology, 2019, 10(6): 692-703.
[9]	JIN Mingming, XU Zengrang. Characteristics of Agricultural and Livestock Products Trade Flows between China and the “Belt and Road” Initiative Region: From the Perspective of Biocapacity [J]. Journal of Resources and Ecology, 2019, 10(6): 584-597.
[10]	ZHOU Yezhi, WANG Juanle, WANG Yi, Elena A. Grigorieva. Estimation of Travel Climate Comfort Degree in the Cross-border Region between China and Russia based on GIS [J]. Journal of Resources and Ecology, 2019, 10(6): 657-666.
[11]	ZHOU Yuke. Greenness Index from Phenocams Performs Well in Linking Climatic Factors and Monitoring Grass Phenology in a Temperate Prairie Ecosystem [J]. Journal of Resources and Ecology, 2019, 10(5): 481-493.
[12]	ZHANG Wenjing. The Situation with College Express Packaging Waste and Recycling Recommendations—Taking the Graduate School of the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences as an Example [J]. Journal of Resources and Ecology, 2019, 10(5): 530-536.
[13]	ZHU He, WANG Jingru, ZHANG Xiyue. Comprehensive Assessment of Sustainable Tourism-oriented Revitalization in a Historic District: A Case Study of Qianmen Area, Beijing, China [J]. Journal of Resources and Ecology, 2019, 10(5): 559-568.
[14]	DOU Qun,ZHANG Zhenya. Analysis on Environmental Pollution in China’s Coastal Ecosystem [J]. Journal of Resources and Ecology, 2019, 10(4): 424-431.
[15]	LI Haifang,LIU Qinghua,LI Shimei,LI Wei,YANG Jinming. Comparison of Soil Moisture in Different Soil Layers between Three Typical Forests in the Upper Reaches of Lijiang River Basin, Southern China [J]. Journal of Resources and Ecology, 2019, 10(3): 307-314.